According to Pew Research Center, between 2004 and 2024, the share of Americans aged 65 and older rose from 12.4% to 18.0%. Subsequently, there are far more senior drivers on the road. Yet regulations around older driver license renewals vary, with no obligation for a vision test in some states.
This study, from Florida car accident lawyer The Schiller Kessler Group, considers how different states handle older driver licensing, and pinpoints the states that feature the highest shares of senior drivers.
It also compares varying state rules with federal crash data to show where older drivers (and other road users) may face comparatively high risk, and looks at senior driver crash data as the number of older drivers on American roads continues to rise.
The States With the Highest Share of Senior Drivers
In 2024, 74 million U.S. licensed drivers were aged 60 or older, a number that represented 30.9% of the country’s 239.8 million drivers, and which was nearly three times that of the under-25 group (11.24%).
There were also 10.97 million drivers aged 80 or older (4.58%) and 4.58 million aged 85 or older (1.91%). These figures mean that one in 22 licensed drivers is at least 80; someone born in 1945 renewing their license in 2024 could legally drive into their 90s in many states.
Vermont features the oldest driving population. In 2024, 38.04% of its licensed drivers were aged 60 or older, which is 23.2% above the national average share. West Virginia was next with a share of 37.99%; Maine (37.00%), New Hampshire (36.92%), and Delaware (36.00%) completed the top five.
All top ten states exceed the national share by at least 10.9%. The ranking favors New England and Appalachia (three of the top four are located in northern New England). Younger, faster-growing states feature smaller shares of senior drivers: examples include Utah (23.0%), Texas and California (26.9% each), and Washington, D.C. (20.6%).
Florida, which ranks 10th by share, ranks second by raw numbers (5.87 million licensed drivers aged 60 or older), behind California (7.47 million) but ahead of Texas (5.25 million), New York (4.00 million) and Pennsylvania (3.12 million). Overall, these five states account for 34.7% of America’s older drivers.
Florida features 1.84 million drivers aged 75 or older, 915,000 aged 80 or older, and another 1.51 million in their early 60s, an indication of future senior driver numbers.
In 2024 in the U.S., 11,995 drivers aged 60 or older were involved in fatal crashes: 22.2% of drivers in fatal crashes with known ages. The rate was 16.2 per 100,000 licensed drivers involved in fatal crashes aged 60 or older.
Top Ten States: Senior Driver Fatal Crashes
Of the top 10 states, Montana featured the highest senior driver fatal crash rate, 21.94 per 100,000 older drivers (67 drivers), followed by West Virginia (19.95), Arkansas (18.68), and Florida (17.32), all of which were above the national rate. Florida recorded the highest number of older drivers involved in fatal crashes among the top 10 states (1,017).
The full top ten list of states featuring the highest senior fatal crash rates is as follows. (Figures are per 100,000 drivers aged 60 or older.)
- Montana (21.94)
- West Virginia (19.95)
- Arkansas (18.68)
- Florida (17.32)
- Maine (15.97)
- Wisconsin (14.58)
- Pennsylvania (13.23)
- Delaware (11.65)
- New Hampshire (10.65)
- Vermont (4.90).
In Wisconsin, drivers aged 60 or older represented 27.7% of all drivers in fatal crashes, the highest share of states in the top 10 and 5.5 percentage points above the national rate. Despite featuring the oldest driving population, just nine of Vermont’s senior drivers perished in fatal crashes (4.9 per 100,000).
Renewal rules vary considerably across the country. According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Vermont and Pennsylvania do not oblige senior drivers to undertake a vision test when they renew their license, despite featuring 3.3 million licensed drivers aged 60 or older combined.
Maine introduces vision tests at 62, while Montana drivers must renew every four years once they reach the age of 75. Arkansas allows drivers aged 70 or older to choose either four- or eight-year renewals.
In Florida, there are no shortened renewal periods or requirements to take a vision test at every renewal until age 80. West Virginia, Delaware, and Wisconsin all observe eight-year renewal cycles for all ages.
As more Americans enter their 70s and 80s, the states that don’t feature strict licensing rules may face increasing pressure to change to serve an aging driving population and potentially worsening road safety circumstances.
Licensing Renewal Requirements for Older Drivers
When an older driver renews their license, tests regarding their vision largely depend on their state of residence.
Seven states (Alabama, Connecticut, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, and Vermont) require no vision test when an older driver renews (according to Insurance Institute for Highway Safety data). Combined, the seven states feature 8.56 million licensed drivers aged 60 or older, including 1.34 million aged 80 or older.
In Tennessee, someone born in 1945 who renewed their license at the age of 80 in 2025 could hold a license until 2033, then renew online without the need for a vision test. Mississippi and Oklahoma allow renewals of up to eight years, while Connecticut retains an eight-year cycle unless drivers aged 65 or older choose a shorter one (in all cases, there are no vision checks).
Arkansas requires a vision check at alternate renewals, which potentially means an 80-year-old on an eight-year cycle could wait 16 years between checks. Oregon tests only during in-person renewals, and allows online renewal every other cycle; New Jersey requires a test just once every 10 years.
Vision Testing and Crash Rates
Crash data from 2024 underscores potential differences. In the seven states that don’t feature renewal vision tests, drivers aged 60 or older were involved in fatal crashes at a combined rate of 18.78 per 100,000 licensed drivers (1,608 drivers). That’s 18.4% above the average rate across the 44 states and Washington, D.C., all of which require some type of vision check.
Mississippi recorded the highest rate (34.30 per 100,000; 244 drivers), which was more than double the national rate (16.20). Oklahoma (26.46), Tennessee (23.47), and Alabama (20.51) also exceeded the national rate; Tennessee recorded 386 older drivers in fatal crashes. Pennsylvania had the highest count among states without testing (413).
However, Vermont (4.90), Connecticut (10.80), and Pennsylvania (13.23) all recorded rates below the national average rate despite lacking vision requirements, which suggests that rural roads, driving distances, and exposure also contribute to results.
Renewal Frequency and Crash Rates
When it comes to renewal frequency and crash rates, the pattern is less consistent. States with eight-year renewals for drivers aged 80 had a combined fatal-crash rate of 17.09 per 100,000 drivers aged 60 or older, compared with 15.74 in states with renewal periods of four years or less for those aged 80 (a difference of about 8.6%).
Some states with short renewal cycles also recorded low rates. Hawaii renews drivers aged 80 or older every two years (7.62), while Rhode Island renews drivers aged 75 or older every two years (5.80). However, New Mexico, which requires yearly renewal from the age of 79, recorded a rate of 23.09 per 100,000.
Twelve states (including Georgia, Kentucky, and New York, plus Washington, D.C.) carry eight-year renewals for those aged 80 or older, yet also demand vision tests during each renewal.
Overall, the data suggests that vision test requirements, as opposed to renewal frequency rates, may provide the most consistent distinction between states. For many senior drivers, local rules can determine when their eyesight is next checked, or if it’s checked at all.
When Was a Senior Driving Law Last Changed?
Most state senior driver rules haven’t changed in recent years, but a few have changed significantly.
Kentucky modified its rules under House Bill 439, signed by Gov. Andy Beshear. The changes mean that, since January 1, 2025, all drivers who renew their license must pass a vision screening test. In 2024, the last full year before the requirement was passed, 252 Kentucky drivers aged 60 or older died in crashes (a rate of 27.22 per 100,000 licensed drivers aged 60 or older); that represented the country’s second-highest rate, 68% above the national average rate (16.20). Future data will illustrate the extent to which screening improves these figures.
Illinois has also made changes, though in this case, to loosen regulations. Its bipartisan Road Safety and Fairness Act (passed in May 2025) took effect on July 1, 2026, raising the mandatory road-test age for renewing drivers from 79 to 87.
That said, drivers aged 79 or older must still pass a vision test. Those aged between 81 and 86 must renew in person every two years, while drivers aged 87 or older must renew every year and pass both vision and driving tests. Despite the change, Illinois continues to retain some of the country’s strictest requirements for older drivers.
In 2024, Illinois recorded a fatal-crash rate of 13.46 per 100,000 older drivers, which was 17% below the national rate and meant the state ranked in 36th place.
According to The Detroit News, in March 2026, Michigan lawmakers recommended regular vision tests for drivers aged 75 or older. Currently, vision checks are only obligatory during in-person renewals (which may occur every other renewal).
With Mississippi and Oklahoma (two of the seven states that don’t feature a mandatory vision test) among the country’s states that feature the highest senior driver fatal crash rates, the issue isn’t just what licensing rules demand, but how recently they’ve been reviewed.
Crash Types and Behaviors Among Seniors
Some older motorists are not necessarily as dangerous as stereotypes may suggest. In 2024, crashes that involved drivers aged 60 or older killed 15.88 people per 100,000 licensed drivers in that age group: that’s 19.9% below the 19.83 rate for drivers under 60 and below the national average rate of 16.37.
These crashes killed 11,762 people, representing 30.0% of 39,254 U.S. traffic deaths, which broadly matches the 30.9% share of licensed drivers aged 60 or older.
Yet senior driver risk increases with age. From a fatality rate of 14.79 per 100,000 for drivers aged between 70 and 74, the rate then rises to 21.22 for drivers aged 85 or older. The oldest group’s rate is 43.5% above the 17.22 for drivers aged between 75 and 79 and 9.6% above the rate for drivers aged between 25 and 59.
Older drivers are also often the victims of fatal crashes: 6,583 (56.0%) of the 11,762 deaths were drivers aged 60 or older, rising to 663 of 972 (68.2%) in crashes involving drivers aged 85 or older.
Speeding, Drunk Driving and Distracted Driving
The three behaviors most associated with road deaths are less of a factor when it comes to senior drivers.
Alcohol was the most common of the three factors for drivers aged 60 or older, with a blood alcohol concentration of .08 or higher involved in an estimated 11.6% of deaths in crashes involving senior drivers (1,382 fatalities). This compares with 31.6% for drivers under the age of 60 and 30.3% nationally (11,904 deaths).
The share declines as drivers age: 16.2% for drivers aged between 60 and 64, 9.3% for drivers aged between 70 and 74, 5.1% for drivers aged 75 or older (201 deaths), and 2.3% for drivers aged 85 or older (23 deaths).
Speeding contributed to 10.2% of deaths in crashes that involved drivers aged 60 or older (1,147 fatalities), compared with 30.4% for drivers under the age of 60 (the national rate was 28.7%).
Distracted driving is the exception, featuring in 5.4% of deaths that involved drivers aged 60 or older (634 fatalities), compared with 7.7% of drivers under the age of 60, which rose to 6.1% among drivers aged 85 or older. Older drivers accounted for 19.8% of 3,205 distraction-related deaths, nearly twice their share of speeding deaths (10.2%) or alcohol-related deaths (11.6%).
The type of distraction also differs for senior drivers compared with those under the age of 60. Among distracted drivers aged 60 or older who died, 62.8% were recorded as being inattentive or “lost in thought,” while 8.8% were using a phone. For drivers under the age of 60, the respective fatality figures were 51.2% and 16.7%.
Intersections, Turning and Visibility
For most older drivers killed in crashes, the three behaviors in question were not a factor during the fatal incident. 73.1% of the drivers killed in 2024 who were aged 60 or older were not speeding, drunk at the wheel, or distracted. This number rose to 81.7% for drivers aged 75 or older, and 85.7% for drivers aged 85 or older (compared with 43.1% of drivers aged under 60 and 51.1% of all drivers).
Instead, fatal crashes often involved turning, timing, and low visibility. Left turns accounted for 14.5% of deaths in crashes that involved drivers aged 60 or older, which rose to 26.0% for drivers aged 85 or older. This exceeds the national share (11.9%) and far exceeds the 6.4% for drivers under the age of 25.
Among drivers aged 85 and over, 48.4% of crash deaths occurred at intersections (compared with 26.6% nationally). Angle (T-bone) collisions accounted for 43.4% of fatal crashes, double the 21.8% for drivers under the age of 60. Daylight crashes were dominant among senior drivers: 82.6% of deaths that involved drivers aged 85 or older occurred during the day, compared with 45.9% of all traffic deaths.
Vehicle Type and Side Impacts
For older drivers, passenger cars pose a particular risk. In 2024, passenger car crashes that involved drivers aged 60 or older killed 3,400 people, including 1,986 older drivers. When drivers older than 60 were involved in fatal crashes, 61.8% died; far more than the share who died in SUVs (49.0%) or pickups (51.0%).
For passenger car drivers aged 85 or older, the death rate reached 76.4% (compared with 45.2% for drivers under the age of 60). Passenger cars accounted for 46.3% of drivers aged 85 or older killed (307 of 663).
Side impacts were particularly deadly: crashes that involved drivers aged 60 or older killed 1,659 people in side-impact collisions, including 937 older drivers (14.2% of all drivers aged 60 or older who were killed). The share rose to 20.8% among drivers aged 85 or older, compared with 9.3% for those under the age of 60.
When an older driver’s car was struck side-on, 71.5% of drivers aged 60 or older died, rising to 78.3% for those aged 75 or older and 80.9% for those aged 85 or older (compared with 58.2% of drivers under the age of 60).
From the data, we can establish the most dangerous combination. Crashes caused while turning and at intersections that feature prominently among older drivers’ fatalities often involve side impact collisions, which means the car is struck at its most vulnerable point.
Scrutiny Levels: Older vs. Younger Drivers
In America, new drivers must earn their license hour by hour; many older drivers can renew for nearly a decade without a vision check.
In 2024, crashes that involved drivers aged 19 or younger killed 43.99 people per 100,000 licensed teen drivers (3,996 fatalities). That’s 2.8 times the 15.88 rate for drivers aged 60 or older.
Many states now feature graduated licensing requirements, with the typical state imposing 50 hours of supervised practice (33 of 50 states require this). Maine requires 70 hours, Pennsylvania 65, and Kentucky, Maryland, and North Carolina all require 60.
Teens must also successfully complete a written test, hold a permit for months, and take a road test. Only three states (Arkansas, Mississippi, and New Jersey) demand no practice hours.
Older Drivers Face Less Scrutiny
Just one state routinely requires road testing at renewal due to a driver’s advanced age. And even in that case (Illinois), the Road Safety and Fairness Act raised its road-test threshold (79 to 87) from July 1, 2026.
In 28 of 51 jurisdictions, drivers aged 80 or older renew according to the same rules that apply to drivers aged 30 or older.
Crash Rates and Licensing Rules
Fatal-crash rates are higher among older drivers in states that don’t require vision tests when renewing. In the seven no-test states, crashes involving drivers aged 60 or older killed 18.78 people per 100,000 licensed older drivers: that’s 19.1% above the 15.54 rate in states that do require some type of vision check.
Mississippi provides a good example. It requires no teen practice hours or vision tests as part of a license renewal and recorded the country’s highest fatality rate among drivers aged 60 or older, 34.30 per 100,000 (244 deaths), which is more than double the national rate. Oklahoma (26.46, fourth) and Tennessee (23.47, seventh) also ranked in the top 10.
States that allow a renewal (irrespective of age) every eight years also feature notable rates: Kentucky (26.35, third) and South Carolina (22.75, ninth).
Evidence Supporting Vision Tests
The National Eye Institute reports that more than half of Americans aged 80 or older either have cataracts or have had them surgically removed. (Cataracts are a readily treatable vision problem primarily suffered by older drivers.)
A landmark JAMA study found that older drivers with cataracts who underwent surgery to remove them subsequently had a 53% lower crash rate than those who did not. A larger Western Australia study of 2,849 drivers aged 60 or older found the risk of a crash dropped 61% in the year after first-eye surgery.
Routine renewal screening could identify treatable cataracts and reduce the likelihood of a crash. As things stand, seven states don’t check an older driver’s vision at all, while others require it only at alternate renewals.
Older Driver Risk and Handing Over Car Keys
In 2024, crashes that involved drivers aged 60 or older killed 10.62 occupants per 100,000 licensed older drivers. And of the 11,762 deaths in crashes involving those drivers, 6,583 (56.0%) were the drivers and 1,281 (10.9%) their passengers. Overall, 66.9% of deaths occurred inside the older driver’s vehicle.
This share rises with age. Drivers aged 60 or older and their passengers accounted for 73.7% of deaths in crashes that involved drivers aged 75 or older; 82.3% in crashes that involved drivers aged 85 or older.
Among passengers killed alongside drivers aged 60 or older, 79.8% were also 60 or older (this rate rose to 91.8% for drivers aged 75 or older and 97.1% for drivers aged 85 or older). To compare, just 9.6% of passengers killed alongside drivers under 60 were aged 60 or older.
Risks to Other Road Users
The risk to those other than an older driver and their passengers is comparatively low. Crashes that involve drivers aged 60 or older killed 2,418 occupants of other vehicles at a rate of 5.26 (20.6%) and 1,480 pedestrians and cyclists (12.6%). That’s 14.6% below the rate for drivers under 60 (6.16) and well below the rate for teen drivers (18.63), who represented 3.5 times the risk.
Rates fell further with age: 4.78 for drivers aged 75 and older and 3.75 for drivers aged 85 and older (rates that are partly due to less driving and fewer night-time and highway trips).
However, older drivers were more likely to be involved in a multi-vehicle crash. Whereas single-vehicle crashes accounted for 35.8% of deaths involving drivers aged 60 or older; for drivers under the age of 60, the figure was 48.2%.
The Costs of Giving up Driving
While keeping older drivers on the road carries risks, older drivers relinquishing their car keys can also lead to significant consequences. A 2024 International Psychogeriatrics review, which screened over 6,000 papers and analyzed 42 studies, linked drivers who stopped driving with depression, anxiety, stress, and declining mental health. Some of the examined drivers suggested stopping driving led to feelings of grief and loss, with some struggling to adjust.
A 2025 review in Transportation Research (Part F) found that more than 80% of 19 studies reported an association between giving up driving and a rise in depressive symptoms.
Additionally, a 2025 report featuring 5,650 older adults from the national Health and Retirement Study linked being unable to drive to depression, both immediately after stopping and over subsequent years. Minimal or no driving was also associated with lower life satisfaction.
The AAA Foundation’s LongROAD study, which followed nearly 3,000 drivers aged between 65 and 79, found that 24.8% reduced how much they drove during the study, including 11.3% who did so for medical reasons. Of those, drivers who covered a relatively small driving range and fewer destinations reported higher levels of depression.
The LongROAD analysis also found that those who switched to alternative transport when they stopped driving immediately suffered increased fatigue levels.
Former drivers in urban areas suffered steep declines in their social roles and activities, while researchers highlighted the necessity of transport support for rural older adults (especially volunteers).
Women and rural residents expected their lack of driving to affect them most severely, while rural drivers were more likely to continue driving despite poor health due to a lack of alternatives.
Balancing Safety and Independence Among Senior Drivers
As America’s 74 million licensed drivers aged 60 or older continue to age, state licensing and vision-testing requirements vary, with some states permitting decade-long renewals without any checks on eyesight. Although older drivers generally pose less risk to other road users compared with younger drivers, the risk of a fatal crash rises with age. Additionally, older motorists who stop driving can suffer when it comes to independence, social connections, and mental health.
Ultimately, to protect drivers, passengers, and other road users, universal regular vision tests and driving assessments for older drivers would surely improve statistics. And when it comes to older drivers’ mental wellbeing and independence, a better selection of accessible transportation alternatives may be of huge benefit.
We know a serious accident can strike at any moment, which is why our 24/7 representatives are waiting to speak to you. Whatever the time, you can contact Florida car accident lawyer The Schiller Kessler Group to schedule a free, no-obligation consultation.
If you have grounds for a claim or lawsuit, we’ll start on your case as soon as we can. And if we take on your case, we won’t charge you an upfront attorney’s fee. Get in touch today for more information.